Wednesday, November 22, 2023

Trip to Washington state, the Olympic Peninsula and the San Juans


[Trip dates August 26-28, 2022.]

Full route itinerary: KCCR - KLMT - 0S9 - KORS - 0S9 - KOLM - KRBG - KCCR. 13+ hrs on the Hobbs.

With Catherine back East for a week, I decided to embark on a longish trip to the Northwest corner of the lower 48 – an area I’ve long wanted to visit, but with weather that I wouldn’t have ventured before getting my instrument rating last fall. Joined by poker pal JT, I set off for Port Townsend and Olympia, Washington, to visit mutual friends, Bay Area transplants we’ve kept up with over the years. The full track over the 3 days is to the left, over a VFR sectional. 

We left around 9:30 on Friday morning in N21348, a C182, enjoying the recently installed G5 and the luxury of not having to reset the DG every 15 minutes. We headed slightly NW from CCR on a route taking us past Mt Shasta, and on to Klamath Falls/Crater Lake for refueling, bathroom break and lunch. If you look closely, you can see some wiggles in the flight track around Redding, where I was giving JT slow flight and stall lessons. 

Klamath is a class D with a lot of military training, though none was happening while we were there.

Leaving KLMT we turned back to the NW, passing Crater Lake and skirting the edge of a fire-fighting TFR. We were initially at 10.5K, but popped up to just under 12.5 for a little while to get above a layer of cumulus and mountain turbulence. I had my pulse oximeter going & could see quite a drop going from 10.5 to 12.5, so we didn’t stay there very long. After passing south of the TFR, we turned more northerly, passing Eugene, Corvallis and Portland on the left and getting great views of the Cascade volcanoes to the right. 

I had been watching the weather intently during the previous week, hoping to get a clear day for a low altitude flyby over Seattle on the way north to Port Townsend. Trying to figure out how to make sightseeing around the SEA class B work, I benefitted from Cunningham’s law: “the best way to get the right answer on the internet is not to ask a question; it's to post the wrong answer”. I posted a proposed route on reddit and asked for feedback, which came quickly: my idea was stupid, it would never work, and here’s what I should do instead. I also discovered that the Boeing Field controllers have a “contact a controller” link on their facebook page & asked for & quickly got details about transitioning through the BFI airspace. 


Mt St Helens, I think (might be Mt Adams)

In the event, on Friday morning the weather in the Seattle area was forecast to be not great, with several cloud layers and low stratus starting around Portland. I filed an IFR plan before we left, starting from a waypoint abeam Mt. St. Helens up to 0S9 (Jefferson County International), planning to activate it only if we had to. When we got close to Portland it was evident that it would be necessary – the area had solid undercast and we could see lots of puffy clouds ahead, so I picked up the clearance from Seattle Center. They routed us up the west side of Puget Sound where I got some rare time in actual IMC. It was mostly quick hits, in & out of cumulus and only a little bumpy. Not too many sights to see on the last leg, at least for me, though JT was enjoying looking at the islands passing down below when we could see them.

Seattle kept us at 8K before handing us off to Whidbey Approach just a few miles short of the field, denying my request for lower. JeffCo has only one approach, the RNAV-A, which is aligned with runway 9 and has a normal descent angle (though it’s labeled “N/A” for some reason), so I assume it’s circling-only because it doesn’t have the right runway markings. (I’m asking for another round of Cunningham’s law here I think.) The controller gave me “direct JAWBN, direct YAYUB, cross JAWBN yadda yadda cleared approach” when we were just a few miles out, leaving me scrambling because JAWBN is not a waypoint on the procedure, though it is shown on the approach plate as a feeder fix off an airway, which we were not on. With some minor missteps, we got aligned with the transition & headed down to the procedure turn at the IAF in plenty of time. (Our friend CK, out at the airport to meet us & watching our flight path on flightradar24 was a bit mystified and thought we were mistakenly heading for Port Angeles, an hour’s drive down the road.) We broke out around 2000 feet, well above the FAF, so despite all the IMC I don’t get to log the approach for currency.

After our Port Townsend friend CK was finished critiquing my landing (“If you’d landed in the touchdown zone you could have made the first taxiway!”) he took us to a very pleasant pub in the old “lower” town by the harbor, where I made quick work of the pint I felt I’d earned. According to CK, the town was the original harbor for the Seattle area but quickly lost out to Seattle/Tacoma when the railway ended there instead of coming all the way out the Olympic peninsula. It has a waterfront area about which you read the same kinds of stories as from SF’s Barbary Coast days (e.g., drunks waking up on a boat to Shanghai) and a “respectable” churchy uptown on the bluffs with some nice old mansions of the local gentry, which now include CK and his wife KK.

The Salish Sea (the name of the whole watery region) has maybe more microclimates than the Bay Area. Saturday dawned with low overcast in Port Townsend, and a very variable forecast for the rest of the day, but mostly clear up towards the San Juan Islands. The three of us (me, JT, CK) decided to try our luck flying up to Orcas Island for lunch. We found the airport lot nearly full – there’s a little restaurant on the field (the Spruce Goose) that’s supposed to have the best pie in the area.

Somewhere in the San Juans

I got a clearance from Whidbey Approach to get us going up through the low stratus (a few hundred feet thick with a base around 1K), found more puffy cumulus above, and quickly got into clear air as we headed north. Even though Orcas is in the US, the airspace is controlled by Victoria Terminal (which should be the name of a character in a William Gibson novel). After the handoff from Whidbey, we quickly cancelled and dropped in to the strip at the north end of the island. So I can now say I’ve talked to a Canadian controller (who politely didn’t correct my calling her “Victoria Approach”).

A short 20 minute walk got us to Eastsound, a harbor town on the south side of the north end of the island (shaped like a ש  with the bottom to the north). After lunch, checking out the farmers’ market and snacking on all the ripe blackberries growing along the path, we got airborne again & had a 30 minute tour of the San Juans before heading back to JeffCo. The direct route across San Juan or Lopez Island to the Olympic Peninsula crosses about 20 miles of open water, so I took a land-hugging route along Whidbey Island through the Naval Air Station’s class C. On Friday I’d heard other GA pilots being told to stay out of the Charlie, but I guess there’s less happening on the weekend, and I got no peep when I headed for the shoreline. The islands are amazingly beautiful. CK does a lot of sailing in the area and was really enjoying the 182’s-eye view from above. He showed his appreciation by offering praise for my landing back at 0S9: “Nice. But aren’t you supposed to land straight?”

Sunday dawned mostly clear in Port Townsend, but the east side of Puget Sound down to Olympia had a broken layer, nixing the idea of a Seattle flyby on the way south. CK dropped us back at the field and I filed another IFR plan, this time picking it up in the air. By the time we got close to Olympia, where our other friends live, it was CAVU, but I flew the approach anyway. The jagged Olympic range was a spectacular contrast with the network of islands, inlets and waterways on our route. 

After second breakfast with our Olympia friends BW and RW we launched for the last long legs home. We made one stop in Roseburg for bathroom break & refueling then quickly got going again. Best gas prices on the trip, in case anyone’s headed up that way. South of RBG we passed a TFR and a towering column of smoke from a fire in southern Oregon near the California border. The next 50-odd miles were pretty murky. Our route took us over terrain up to almost 8K and it started getting bumpy at 9.5k. Climbing another 2000 feet smoothed things out for the rest of the ride and got us above a lot of the smoke. Somewhere in there over rugged terrain we picked up an ELT signal on 121.5, which I relayed to the controller.

We soon passed the Trinity Alps off to the west and could see Shasta again off to the right. Another 90 minutes had us back in Concord. Total distance ~1400 nm. 13+ on the Hobbs. Not a cheap outing, and a lot of time in the seat, but lots of fun.

Thanks to JT for the photos.


From now on this is going to be a Flying Blog

Mostly a place to keep a record of interesting places to go, good routes and Stuff that Happened.

First post - my new favorite route from Concord to Half Moon Bay. I found this via a youtube video but haven't seen it described anywhere in detail. Yet based on controller familiarity it seems to be well known. [Correction: this is the SW Bay Flyway shown on the SF FLY chart.] From Concord, the route goes through the Oakland Charlie directly over the field, then the San Mateo bridge midspan, through the SQL Delta and then a climb over the peninsula ridge before descending to HAF. It's pretty much the shortest route outside the SFO Bravo. If you're programming it into your navigator, it's KCCR - OAK - VPMID - KSQL - KHAF.  The OAK waypoint is not exactly right - the instruction will be to cross the Coliseum then head for the 30 numbers (assuming, as is essentially always the case in nice weather, that OAK is landing to the northwest). I now have those spots set up as VOR/radial/distance waypoints in Foreflight. But you're navigating VFR, so you can adjust as needed without the programming.

Unusually, the first call leaving CCR is to OAK tower (north, the GA one), not NorCal. My habit is to climb to 3K out of CCR [update: 2.5K is sufficient] and listen on the OAK tower frequency as soon as I'm clear of the CCR Delta. You can only hear the pilot side until getting above 2K and within about 15 miles. Once you hear the tower, call them up. They'll descend you to 2K approaching the field. Nearing the coliseum they'll switch you to the south tower which will send you over the 30 #'s, descend you to 1.4K & send you to the midspan. Before reaching the bridge, they'll ship you to SQL for that transition. SQL's D goes right up to the B shelf. My personal custom is to ask for the transition. It's never been denied. I suppose worst case if they refuse entry you could turn south and go through the gap between SQL and PAO airspace.

The B shelf is at 1.5K along that stretch. Very likely you'll cross under SFO arrivals, often two landing in parallel on 28L & R. If they're not too busy, SQL may offer to switch you to NorCal, but by the time you cross over there you're nearly at HAF so I no longer bother. Leaving that B shelf, you can now climb to 2.5 or 3K to cross the ridgeline. 

Lots of altitude changes but very scenic. Here is a recent track log.

Update: Approaching HAF from the south or east, my preference is now to arrive southwest of the runway, cross midfield and join the 30 downwind from the runway side. Joining on the 45 as shown in this track puts you uncomfortably close to terrain. Even when it's busy you can easily spot other traffic and find an opening.


Thursday, July 30, 2015

I'm Not Worried About the Drought

With an El Niño year looming I'm optimistically looking forward to a great ski season. Though the drought may be over shortly, we've still been doing our small part to reduce water use, cutting our yard watering by 40% since 2013. There's a lot of brown out there now. Other Californians now have about 30 gallons per day more from our common supply. You're welcome.

Just today I read a story about the impending disappearance of the Ogallalla aquifer east of the Rockies, due to the fact that plains farmers have been pumping water out of it 10 times faster than its natural recharge rate. That's just the latest in a regular drumbeat of scary stories about how, thanks to the tragedy of the commons (where no individual farmer has any incentive to conserve, because his neighbor's pumps will drain the same water source as his), the aquifers of the West will soon be gone. The other day someone brought up the seemingly outrageous amount of water used by almonds, and the fact that California farmers in some areas are still planting new trees, even as others have to let theirs die.

Someone else asked me recently whether I was worried. I'm not. It's a commonplace observation that urban users account for only 20% of the total water used in California. And much of that goes to water peoples' yards in the hotter inland areas. The densest urban areas account for a small fraction of the state's total. So we're really not at risk of running out in the parts of the state where people want to live and where most of the economic activity happens.

What might happen (unless the farmers can get past their libertarian principles and work together) is that some farms will be abandoned and some foods will get more expensive. Probably not by much, though. (Although California is now the almond capital of the world, it didn't used to be, and I don't remember almonds being unaffordable when they were part of my regular snack supply as an impoverished grad student in the early '80s.) But even if some items get much more expensive, for most of us and for most of these items, their cost is just not that big a part of our budget. (I know there are lots of food-insecure people out there. I don't think they're mainly buying almonds and local beef. There are many places in the world that can produce caloric staples cheaply, and we can import all that stuff. I'm pretty sure I read a year or two ago that much of our cheap ground beef already comes from South America.) If parts of the plains turn to desert and the western side of the Central Valley has to be abandoned for farming, so be it. Bummer for those independent-spirited farmers, but I don't see why urban Californians should be concerned, other than in the general sense of being sympathetic about someone else's misfortune.

People have this notion that we must "do something" about the drought. Well, in principle a long enough drought would make the urban areas uninhabitable. But we're pretty far from that scenario. In any case there's little we can or need to do about that long term right now -- we don't even know if it's coming. Urbanites can cut back on their water use, but that won't help the farmers. And if the farmers refuse to work together to make efficient use of their collective groundwater resource, they're the main ones who will suffer the consequences. Although California has new laws that will eventually limit and manage groundwater use, lobbying by agribiz produced legislation that doesn't fully take effect for another 25 years. If the primary victims of the drought don't want to work together to solve their problem, that doesn't make it my problem.

So my main worry is that the El Niño won't materialize, and it'll be another crappy ski season. Please don't hit me.

Friday, November 21, 2014

A eulogy for Tammy

In her classroom. Photo by Jennifer Kelleher, one of her students.
When Tammy was a baby, I played peek-a-boo with her and got big laughs. In memory, her laughter was already outsized.

When she was 3 she wanted to be a ballerina. I gave her my red plastic fireman's hat and told her that if she wore that she'd be even better: a ballerina clerk. She wore it for days.

Don't ask what it meant. It was just early days of brotherly torture. But she wasn't defenseless. When she was 9 or 10, I got on the phone extension while she was talking with a friend. She responded with one of the most devastating insults one could deliver in our house: she said I was just like Nixon because I bugged people on the phone.

I told her she should credit me for her great sense of humor on the grounds that she had to have one in order to survive being my little sister. But that was just more teasing. Even in the last year, as she fought the disease and suffered the effects of the treatment, she'd reward a phone call with laughs and without complaints.

Witnessing the outpouring of love and affection she's received over the last few months reminds me of a lesson of that great 20th century american philosopher, The Wizard of Oz. As he told the Tin Man: Your heart is judged not by how much you love, but by how much you are loved by others. (He also said that hearts will never be practical until they can be made unbreakable.) Tammy's small frame held a huge heart.

Rest in peace, Tammy.

Friday, December 13, 2013

Another way the World Can End

I just found this paper from 12 years ago by Dar and De Rujula. It's about another way life on earth can be (mostly) snuffed out and might also explain why there are no old advanced civilizations. It's another variant on the world ending in fire. And unlike extinction by giant asteroid, we don't have the technology to do anything about it.

Dar is at the Technion and De Rujula at CERN. Their paper looks at what happens when a gamma ray burst (GRB) goes off in our galaxy. A GRB, visible somewhere in the cosmos about 3 times every day, is thought to be either the dying blast of a high mass supernova, in which the core collapses to either a neutron star or a black hole or the merger of two neutron stars. In either case, the combination of high angular momentum, trapped magnetic field and extreme kinetic energies - comparable to the entire rest mass of the star or stars - results in a few-second long blast of energy beamed along the opposite poles of the rotating system. We see a fraction of this energy as gamma ray photons. These two beams are tightly collimated by a combination of magnetic fields and relativistic effects, with opening angles thought to be no more than a few milliradians. That's how we can see them all the way across the universe -- an appreciable fraction of the supernova's total energy goes into these tightly focused beams. When one of them happens to point in our direction, it's bright enough to outshine everything else in the sky at gamma ray energies, even from billions of light years away.

If one of these things goes off in our own galaxy, though, we could be in trouble. Anything sufficiently close - and the center of the galaxy, 25,000 light years away, is apparently, close enough -- gets blasted with radiation. For us, it's not the direct gamma rays that are the problem. Our atmosphere blocks those pretty effectively. GRBs weren't even noticed until the 1960s, when, during the cold war, the US launched satellites designed to detect nuclear bomb blasts. (Above ground tests were banned by treaty in the early '60s.) Being above the atmosphere, they could see the GRB gamma rays.

However, once the gammas (and any other cosmic ray stuff -- protons and heavier nuclei swept up in the blast) hit the upper atmosphere, their interactions with atmospheric atoms produce a copious shower of high energy particles. The result of this air shower is a flood of high energy muons. Muons are heavy enough to zip by atomic electrons without being significantly scattered or deflected, not affected by the strong interaction, making them highly penetrating, and sufficiently long-lived for most of those created in the upper atmosphere to reach the surface. In fact, several (created by ordinary cosmic rays) go through you every second as you read this. They pass easily through the lower atmosphere and hundreds of meters of water or rock, and deposit all of their energy along the way. This puts them in a really nasty "sweet spot" of particle properties to cause trouble. Protons, which are heavier, interact strongly with atomic nuclei and lose energy before reaching the ground. Electrons are so light that they get scattered before going very far. Neutrinos just zip right through everything without losing any energy. Other particles like pions (aside from being strongly interacting) are too short-lived to reach the surface.

The net effect from the muons is a ~10 second zap of high energy radiation deposited in anything on the earth's surface or in the shallower parts of the ocean. According to the paper, a GRB at the distance of the center of the galaxy would, if pointed right at us, have enough energy to sterilize the planet's surface. Thanks to associated cosmic rays, which would follow the initial gamma pulse for a few days, no part of the planet would be safe. Dar and De Rujula calculate that a person at sea level would receive hundreds of times the fatal dose of radiation. Only the hardiest, smallest or deepest ocean life forms would have a chance of survival. Also, just for extra fun, there'd be a global firestorm from the thermal pulse in the upper atmosphere, like in the asteroid strike scenario.

Because the gamma burst comes from a supernova, it should also be accompanied by a neutrino pulse, and these might precede the gammas by seconds or minutes, because they are produced early in the collapse and escape almost immediately. The neutrinos would be imperceptible except to a few large experiments like IceCube. It seems unlikely that, even if correctly interpreted, the warning would help anyone very much. The only place to ride out the initial radiation blast would be deep underground. And the surface that anyone who happened to be down in one of these mines (such as physics grad students minding an experiment) would return to would be sterilized by the blast and the firestorm. Life would survive in the deep oceans and also among smaller, hardier critters (like these) that are able to withstand and repair cellular damage.

The paper's authors calculate an expected rate for getting caught by one of these blasts at roughly once per 100 million years. The nearest star likely to undergo this kind of supernova is Eta Carinae, but apparently its spin axis isn't pointing at us, though it's expected to blow sometime in the next million years or so. There's been some speculation that one or more of the handful of mass extinctions seen in the fossil record was due to one of these events, with arguments recently made for one about 450 million years ago as a candidate. (Oddly, while there are several later papers on the same general subject, no one seems to reference this paper. I'm not sure if that means it's wrong or if this is some petty turf thing.)

Anyway, this is another interesting way for the world to end, up there with the solar system wandering into a black hole or metastable vacuum decay. Always fun to think about!

UPDATE: A new paper suggesting that GRBs make most galaxies inhospitable to complex life. http://physics.aps.org/articles/v7/124. Doesn't mention the muon shower effect though. In fact I haven't found a later paper that references the one at the top. Maybe there's something wrong with the calculations, but de Rujula is a big name, so I doubt it's egregiously wrong.

Wednesday, November 27, 2013

A pseudo-debate on GE salmon

Interesting "debate" between Paul Greenberg, an opponent of GE technology and Elliot Entis, the former CEO AquaBounty Technologies. They've used GE to create a faster-growing salmon, which is to be raised in large (inland) fish tanks on primarily plant-based feed (in contrast to conventional farmed salmon which requires primarily fish-based feed). I put "debate" in quotes because the nature of the discussion doesn't resemble a real discussion so much as a bout of eel-wrestling. Entis repeatedly shows Greenberg's claims to be either mistaken or internally inconsistent (e.g,. arguing for "sustainability" at the same time as opposing GE salmon that requires less fish-meal input per unit of output), at which point Greenberg just raises some other point, without ever providing a rebuttal. I don't see how anyone can read this and come away thinking that Greenberg has made a case.

For anyone going to the link and deciding tl;dr; here's a key exchange. The earlier back-and-forth concerns also questions of "ownership" of the breed, environmental impact, labeling and profit.
Greenberg: But what about the fact that traditional growers who may not want to farm with modified stock will find themselves at a competitive disadvantage. That they may in fact be obliged to buy salmon juveniles exclusively from AquaBounty. Is that ethical? Is that good for the world?

Entis: I am confused by your raising the question of ethics. Are you really suggesting that improving a product so that people will prefer it is unethical because people with an inferior product will be disadvantaged? Is that what you would have written when the first Model T rolled off the line and the horse and buggy industry cried foul? Your "ethical" objection can be raised against any new invention or product. Do I hope salmon farmers will buy the AquAdvantage eggs? Of course, and then the farmers, consumers, and the environment will benefit. I think that is pretty ethical. 
Greenberg: I suppose it depends on what your definition of an “inferior product” would be. I know you have absolute faith in the safety of your salmon, but others would rather take a longer range view and wait and see if it is truly safe. DDT and PCBs were once considered “safe” in the general marketplace. We only saw their profound impact on the environment decades later.

Entis: Paul how long is the long range? Ten years? A hundred? This argument is the refuge of those who would prefer that this fish and any product of biotechnology never see the commercial light of day.

Very little in our world is perfectly knowable, but over the years I believe that the systems for judging knowable risk have improved in quality and comprehensiveness. I also know that analysis of DDT, PCBs, and other chemical agents used in the past did not undergo 15 or more years of safety research, as has the AquaBounty salmon. I can also point out with no fear of contradiction that no fish has undergone as much testing and analysis as the AquAdvantage Atlantic salmon.
After this exchange, where pretty much every claim Greenberg makes has been countered, Entis asks whether his mind has been changed at all. Greenberg says, in effect, that nothing he learns about this could change his view. So much for open-mindedness.

Saturday, October 26, 2013

Does warning your daughter that sexual assault is a risk of binge drinking make you a "rape apologist"?

[Updated: Quote from an article by Slate's legal correspondent Emily Bazelon at the end.]

The interwebs have been lit up over the last couple of weeks about how to talk (or write) about "rape culture" and the hazards faced by women who get blitzed at parties. I gather from some of what I read that this has been an ongoing point of anger within a segment of the feminist community, but I was stunned at the outpouring of vitriol in response to a column by Slate writer Emily Yoffe, "College Women: Stop Getting Drunk" (title probably provided by her editor) with subtitle "It’s closely associated with sexual assault. And yet we’re reluctant to tell women to stop doing it." The article made many points that struck me - and from comments evidently a lot of other readers - as perfectly sensible, motherly advice. To wit: there are predatory men out there, and women who get drunk - especially to the point where they lose control - are putting themselves at risk of becoming rape victims. This seems no more controversial than telling kids to look both ways before they cross the street, but evidently there's a long history of some sort of feminist view that any advice to women about how to stay safe amounts to "apologizing" for or "denying" the "rape culture", victim blaming and slut shaming. Apparently the only correct way to talk about rape is to talk about the men who are raping. Parents should "tell their sons not to rape". But they should never ever warn their daughters about the risks of being incapacitated by drugs or alcohol. Because that's just blaming the victims.

I've read a bunch of these feminist manifestos, and I still don't get it. [I use the word "feminist" here as a shorthand for the people espousing these views. I consider myself a feminist in the sense that I don't think gender should be grounds for discrimination, and I want my daughter to find the world entirely open to her in every respect, unlike, say, the way it is for Saudi women. But that doesn't mean I haven't warned her about the risks of alcohol.] This hoo-hah came in the wake of the news of two teenage girls from a small Missouri town who went to a party at the house of some HS football players, got passed-out drunk, were raped by some of the boys, then dropped off at their homes (one semiconscious and unable to get in her front door on a freezing night). After a subsequent investigation by the police and local prosecutor, charges against the boys were dropped; the reasons are disputed, but I don't think anyone openly argues that what the boys did wasn't rape or was OK. The "rape culture" meme is, I think, about the macho jock culture that tells guys that anything they do to score is OK, including sticking it in a drunk passed out 13 year old. I'm pretty sure that's a real thing, not just a feminist fantasy. But it seems hard to argue that the bulk of society is OK with this kind of thing - people all over the world were shocked at the Maryville story. It's no more acceptable than was the Matthew Shepard murder in the late '90s or the bullying that pushed a S. Hadley, Mass. girl to suicide a few years ago. It's bad shit and pretty much everyone agrees that it's bad shit and we should keep working to keep it from happening again. Humankind being what we are, it seems unlikely that these efforts will ever be completely successful.

What doesn't always happen in these rape cases is for the justice system to punish the perpetrators. The feminist claim is that when it doesn't happen it's because police, prosecutors and judges don't take it seriously. That might also sometimes be true, though it seems uncontroversial that the lack-of-consent part of a rape conviction is going to be tricky to prove in situations where the woman can't recall exactly what happened, particularly since there's such a thing as consensual sex, sometimes after drinking. Obviously that doesn't apply to cases like Maryville, but that's not what's being debated. What many of these folks are saying is that drunk consent is not consent, period, end of story. I don't know what these people's experience of the real world is - how many times they've gotten it on with someone after a few drinks. I'm guessing it doesn't heavily inform their polemics. The criminal justice system is a very blunt instrument for "solving" the complexity of interpersonal relationships.

[A case that got Yoffe a lot of flack from the same merry band is one where a married woman wrote to her (as "Dear Prudence") about how she & her husband drank, then got into bed & started going at it but she doesn't remember everything and is now really upset. ("I liked it and went along, only to wake up in the morning and remember only half of it.") Yoffe's response was not sympathetic, except to the woman's husband. Apparently, though she should just have told the woman that yes, her husband is a rapist and she should divorce him. This woman is a rape survivor who is being slut-shamed by Yoffe. (There's a much more nuanced response by Lindsay Beyerstein here. Though I don't agree with everything she says, she shows much more sensitivity to the unusual aspect of the story than the rest of the dial-at-11 rants of outrage.)]

There's a lot more along these lines at the websites Jezebel, Feministing, Salon and even on Slate, where Amanda Hess wrote a piece subtitled "We can prevent the most rapes on campus by putting our efforts toward finding and punishing perpetrators, not by warning their huge number of potential victims to skip out on parties." The theme is that its so tired to be warning women about the risks of alcohol - they all have heard it a thousand times - and so the only thing that needs to be written about is how we're going to lock up all the rapists.

What all this seems to miss is the completely straightforward observation that it's a risky world out there right now. All the good intentions in the world about "changing the rape culture" don't change it tomorrow. As Yoffe says in her reply: "In the meantime, this weekend, some young, intoxicated women will wake up next to guys they never wanted to sleep with. I believe it’s worth talking about how keeping within a safe drinking limit can potentially help young women avoid such situations." A common thread I notice in many of the replies is how young the writers are. I'm guessing they don't have daughters yet, and aren't thinking about this issue from the very immediate perspective of their daughter's safety today and tomorrow. (Though one of the more ridiculous pieces is by Soraya Chemaly, who has young boys.) Their responses are purely political: to give safety advice to girls is a distraction from the only correct path, telling boys not to be rapists. Chemaly says "These are profoundly systemic problems, and this approach - taking up valuable time and space -  is counter-productive." Umm… there’s a lot of space on the internet. And “counterproductive”? It's not like we can't walk and chew gum at the same time.

This is a subject that seems to invite analogies in the blog comments, such as about not wandering into a bad part of town with $100 bills poking out of your pocket. (Which does seem to verge on telling women not to dress “seductively”, though that's not how it's meant.) But to continue the one that I started with: when we tell our children to look both ways before crossing the street – even though they have the right to be in the crosswalk and cars are required to stop for them, and this is the tenth time we've said it – are we being apologists and enablers of the car-centric aggressive driving culture? (Also, taking up valuable time!) Or are we just giving them utterly commonsense instruction in how not to get hurt?

[Update]
A month after the Yoffe article, Emily Bazelon, Slate's legal correspondent wrote another, using a study on underreporting of drinking-related rape as a basis to defend Yoffe from the PC gang. Closing paragraph:
In the vast majority of sexual assaults, Krebs says, the victim knows the offender. And sometimes she may not remember exactly what happened—because her memory is blurred by intoxication. That’s why Emily Yoffe called for rape prevention education that reaches women as well as men. Not instead of men—of course we need to make clear that men who force sex are fully responsible for their violence, no matter what the circumstances. But we also should treat women as fully capable of agency by giving them the information they need to understand that binge drinking is a risk factor for sexual assault. I’m the mother of sons, not daughters. It is absolutely my responsibility to teach my boys that there is no excuse—none—for having sex unless they can be absolutely sure the other person wants to. But if I had girls, I would want to open their eyes to the reality that drinking to the point of passing out will make them more vulnerable. That doesn’t mean blaming them. It means arming them.